Buydown comparison
Temporary vs permanent mortgage buydowns
Temporary buydowns create early payment relief. Permanent buydowns trade more cash now for a lower rate over time. The better structure depends on who pays, your future payment comfort, and how long you expect to keep the loan.
Lenny's take
Choose a temporary buydown for transitional payment relief; choose permanent points only when the break-even fits your timeline.
Neither structure is automatically cheaper. A temporary buydown is often funded by a seller or builder and expires. Permanent points are an upfront cost tied to a lower note rate.
When a temporary buydown can make sense
- A permitted seller or builder is paying without raising the price beyond the home's supportable value.
- You can afford the full note-rate payment when the temporary subsidy ends.
- The subsidy is more useful than an alternative concession, such as closing-cost help.
- The loan program and transaction permit the structure.
When permanent points can make sense
- The monthly savings are meaningful and documented on comparable Loan Estimates.
- You have enough cash left after closing for reserves and near-term priorities.
- Your expected holding period is comfortably longer than the break-even.
- You are not likely to refinance before recovering the upfront cost.
Compare both without being misled
Use the full note-rate payment for the temporary buydown and calculate the points break-even for the permanent option. Then compare the same loan amount, term, product, lock period, and lender-controlled fees. A low introductory payment and a low permanent rate answer different questions.
Use your numbers
Move from explanation to comparison.
Lenny can analyze a Loan Estimate or compare matched rate offers using the same cost-and-timeline logic.
Official sources
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide: Temporary Interest Rate Buydowns
- Freddie Mac Seller/Servicer Guide: Temporary Subsidy Buydowns
- CFPB: Lender credits and discount points
Educational guidance only. Examples are hypothetical and do not include every loan cost or program rule. Final terms, pricing, eligibility, and disclosures must be confirmed by a licensed mortgage lender. Reviewed July 27, 2026.
